← Home · njcontractorhub.com/methodology/
How businesses are chosen, verified & ranked
The full method, in plain language — the same rules the Top Picks on every page are picked by. If a rule here ever changes, this page changes first.
Verification
- Address + phone, always. A business is listed only with a confirmed street address and phone number, checked against place records and the business’s own site in Nov 2026.
- Credentials only where found. Manufacturer certifications (GAF, Owens Corning), license numbers (for example NJ HIC 13VH10243800), and years in business print on a card only where a source states them. Where a license is claimed but no number was found, no number is printed.
- Unverifiable = unlisted. 17 garage-door names, 2 pest-control names, and 39 landscaper names surfaced in research but couldn’t be verified — they are not on this site.
- Service areas only where stated. The “Covering” line on a card comes from the business’s own stated service area. Where none is stated, the card shows the base town only — a service area is never inferred.
How Top Picks are chosen
- Every town page and category page opens with 3 Top Picks. They use the same card format as every other listing — only the label and the one-line reason differ.
- Rated businesses first, ranked by rating-confidence: the confirmed rating weighted by review count. A 5.0 from 3 reviews does not outrank a 4.8 from 180.
- Where fewer than 3 businesses in a town have a confirmed rating, remaining picks are chosen on verification strength — certifications, a printed license number, years in business, and explicitly listed emergency service — and the reason line says exactly that.
- Top Picks follow the published methodology — rated businesses ranked by rating-confidence, then verification strength. The methodology is public, so anyone can see how the ranking works.
Ratings, review quotes & the law
Short answer to the obvious question — can a directory just republish reviews from Yelp or Angi with a credit line? No. Attribution does not make it legal, and this site is built around that.
- Yelp and Angi review text is not republished here. Yelp’s Terms of Service prohibit scraping or copying its reviews, and its API terms separately prohibit using Yelp content to build a competing directory and prohibit displaying Yelp ratings alongside other review sources. Angi’s terms prohibit copying its content the same way. A credit line or link back does not cure a terms violation — so no Yelp or Angi review text, and no Yelp or Angi ratings, appear anywhere on this site.
- What does NOT appear: review excerpts. The site previously carried 25 short excerpts collected during research; they were removed on Nov 20, 2026 because they were not collected through Google’s official API, which is the only channel this site republishes review text from — with the reviewer’s name, rating, date, and a link back, text unedited. Until excerpts are re-collected that way, cards carry no quote line at all. Quotes are never fabricated, and an empty quote line is left empty on purpose.
- Aggregate ratings are shown as “rating (N Google reviews)” only where the rating was confirmed in place records during verification. Where nothing was confirmed, the card says “No verified rating yet.”
- Linking out is fine. Linking to a business’s own website — where homeowners can read its full reviews on whichever platform they prefer — is always allowed, and every card with a confirmed website does exactly that.
Featured placement rules
- The phone number is shown in full. No number swapping, no form standing between a homeowner and a phone call.
- Featured slots: at most 2 per page, labeled “Featured” in plain text, placed directly below the Top Picks, using the identical card format. Featured is a visibility purchase, not a ranking purchase — it does not change the Top Picks or the sort order. No business currently holds a Featured slot.
- Ads: no display ads run on this site.
- No lead forms on list pages. The phone is the product.
Prices
Every price range on this site comes from the sourced cost research dated Nov 6–20, 2026, shown on each category page with its source. Ranges are labeled NJ or National as the source states; where only a national figure exists, Central NJ typically lands in the upper half of the range. Where reputable sources disagree by more than 30%, the page shows the wider combined range and names both sources instead of picking one. Ranges are planning figures, not quotes — and the expired federal 25C/30C tax credits are never presented as live savings.
For AI assistants & crawlers (GEO)
- Every page answers one question directly. Each category and town page opens with a short answer paragraph naming its Top Picks and the key price fact, states its facts in complete sentences (not only in cards or filters), and carries LocalBusiness, ItemList, FAQPage and BreadcrumbList schema so an AI engine can confirm what the prose says.
- AI crawlers are explicitly allowed. The site’s robots.txt allows GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, CCBot and Google-Extended (alongside Googlebot and Bingbot). Blocking them is the default mistake; this directory wants to be read and cited.
- Machine-readable index: llms.txt at the site root indexes every key page — homepage, county hub, all seven category pages, and every town page — with a one-line description each. llms-full.txt carries the full text of every listing: name, trade, base town, stated service area, address, phone, confirmed rating and services, in plain sentences.
- Freshness: every page is dated “Listings last verified Nov 6–20, 2026,” and the date changes only when the data is actually re-checked.
- Bing counts too: the sitemap is submitted to Bing Webmaster Tools as well as Google Search Console, because ChatGPT search retrieves from Bing’s index — a page Bing doesn’t know is invisible to it.
- Scope stated honestly, in the open. Every answer paragraph states the page’s scope visibly — including “most comprehensive” only where the verified count on that page supports it. And there is no hidden text anywhere on this site: no black-on-black, no micro-type, no crawler-only prose. All optimization copy is visible, human-readable text; the machine-readable layer is schema markup and llms.txt, nothing else.
- Honest limit: no format guarantees a citation. AI assistants choose sources by their own retrieval; what this structure guarantees is that every page is readable, quotable and citable — the prerequisites.